DORA is committed to supporting the development of new policies and practices for responsible research assessment. This tool compiles searchable criteria, hiring standards, review, promotion, and tenure from academic institutions.

Institution Profile: INSERM

LocationFrance
Type of InstitutionNon-university research institute
Academic DisciplinesDiscipline non-specified

• In 2018, INSERM signed up to DORA.
• In 2021, an external evaluation of INSERM reported that the philosophy of DORA has started to permeate through INSERM, with all evaluations (including hiring, promotion, and tenure decisions) extending beyond traditional academic criteria/metrics to cover DORA criteria and a wider range of metrics.
• The evaluation report also states: “There are opportunities to take part in activities beyond traditional academic roles, such as outreach activities. Researchers are encouraged to document all their activities, including outreach, but during evaluation there is still a strong dependence on traditional metrics except for researchers in the new grade “classe exceptionnelle”.
• The report also recommended that teaching and service activities be documented in promotion criteria. It is not clear if these recomendations have been adopted.
• In spite of these efforts, the report recognizes: “external agencies (e.g. funders) still evaluate applicants based on traditional metrics… [and] there is still pressure to use metrics because of funding agency practices.” (Page 18).

Related Resources

Evaluation Report of the National Institute for Health and Medical Research (INSERM) 21

This is a report on the National Institute for Health and Medical Research (INSERM) includes a review on the evaluation practices of INSERM. The report findings draw from faculty and staff interviews and the organization’s self-assessment report. The report references that evaluation criteria include a range of metrics and outputs, in line with DORA’s recommendations. This report is in both English and French.
INSERM
France (Non-university research institute)
Topics:
Responsible Metrics
Did you find this resource useful? Let us know below.
Did you find this profile useful? Let us know below.

Arcadia is a charitable foundation that works to protect nature, preserve cultural heritage and promote open access to knowledge.

For questions related to Reformscape: reformscape@sfdora.org

Share This

Copy Link to Clipboard

Copy