This internal report for the University of Waikato investigates researchers’ perspectives on metrics and their influence on research impact, highlighting a multifaceted view of the role these metrics play in the academic landscape. While researchers generally acknowledged the usefulness of metrics, they were concerned about the over-reliance on these metrics, which can lead to a narrow focus on quantifiable outcomes at the expense of broader, qualitative contributions. Many researchers emphasized the need for a balanced approach that integrates both quantitative and qualitative assessments to more accurately reflect the true impact and value of research.
Researchers also expressed apprehension about the potential for metrics to be misused, leading to consequences such as the prioritization of certain types of research over others, or the manipulation of data to achieve higher scores. There is a strong call within the research community for the development of more sophisticated and nuanced evaluation frameworks that recognize the diversity of research outputs and impacts. This includes advocating for greater transparency in how metrics are applied, and a more inclusive approach that considers the unique characteristics and contributions of different research disciplines.
Chivers M, Howie J, Apiata AH, McCallum F, Smith GMP, Apete K, Cassin M, Chen Y (2023). Exploring researchers’ views on Metrics and research impact: Internal report. https://hdl.handle.net/10289/16014